Preview: 2012 WFTDA East Region Playoffs
-
Bonnie Thunders leads a overwhelmingly favored Gotham team: the New Yorkers have an all-time 15-1 record dating back to the very first East region playoffs in 2007. Photo: Axle Adams. -
Charm City has finished third behind Philly in each of the last two East playoffs -- this time, they start off as the 4th seed. Photo: Tyler Shaw. -
3 seed Montreal claimed their highest ranking ever in the region on the strength of a 153-131 upset over Charm City at ECDX. Photo: Dave Wood. -
7th seed Boston celebrates after winning a dramatic game over a (then-stronger) Arizona team at ECDX. Photo: Dave Wood. -
In 2011, Carolina was the first of London's three upset victims; this year, London comes in as the 6 seed while Carolina holds 8. Photo: Tyler Shaw. -
Steel City had a tough time with Gotham in last year's playoff semifinals; this time, they'll have to defeat Charm City in their first game if they want to have a chance to advance to Championships. Photo: Tyler Shaw. -
9 seed Dutchland has had a lot of turnover since their controversy-laden 2011 appearance in the playoffs; this year, they'll have a second opportunity to face Gotham if they can beat 8 seed Carolina in the tournament opener. Photo: Tyler Shaw. -
10 seed DC just barely missed the playoffs last year after appearances in 2009 and 2010; this time they pull 7 seed Boston as their first opponent. Photo: James Calder.
BURLINGTON, VT -- It’s weekend three of the four-week cycle of the WFTDA regional playoffs. After the intensity of the upset-heavy North Centrals and last weekend’s West Playoffs -- a tournament that saw four of the five placement bouts come down to the last jam -- it would appear on paper that the historically more stable East Playoffs may be a little less hectic.
See WFTDA's official tournament bracket here.
In 2011, the East Playoffs saw a total of three upsets in 17 games, all involving bottom-ranked London rolling over higher-ranked opposition. While the number one position is as locked in stone as it ever has been and probably ever will be, there's plenty to fight for below it. Philly have looked in fine fettle this year too, with their undefeated run at RollerCon showing they are probably hitting form at the right time, but it almost certainly won't be enough to stop throw a spanner in the Gotham machine given the teams' recent history.
The only way Philly will find themselves fighting for third is by losing to the winner of London and Montreal, which would require quite the turnaround from either team. Montreal come in as the third seed for the first time and would be favorites to progress as the third-place team regardless of any other factors given their ECDX win over four-ranked Charm City, the region's perennial third-place finishers of late.
The external factors only serve to boost Montreal's case -- the return of stand-out 2011 stars Smack Daddy and Iron Wench to the Montreal roster can only help them build on their best results of 2012 and push for a first visit to Championships. But would it be enough to get past a Philly side that beat them by 145 points in May? The chances don’t look good -- but both sides beat Charm City by about the same margin during the season, so it's not entirely outside the realm of possibility. Could London upset Philly if they repeat their 2011 win over the Canadians? The Liberty Belles were the only side to beat the transatlantic interlopers at NIghtmare on 95, by a solid 140-53 margin, with the margin almost entirely due to a crushing first half performance. If London are in a position to post a better result than that this year is anybody's guess.
Steel City sit at five and are Charm's first challenge if the All-Stars want to repeat their performance in 2010 and 2011 and reclaim third place in the east. Steel have put up some good results since their loss to Montreal in June and may well fancy their chances; their hopes will probably be boosted by the last-minute losses of Just Carol and Holly Gohardly for Charm City, who have both been lost to injury in recent weeks.
London at six are as unknown a quantity as ever. They put up a record-breaking score against Auld Reekie, but failed to make much of an impression with a narrower-than-expected win over newly minted full WFTDA members of Bear City to get their in-region games in. The result of their recent game against Team USA in London compares favorably with Philly's result at RollerCon--but as the USA rosters for those two games were markedly different, direct comparisons are hard.
Boston come into regionals where they left last year, at seven; they'll be hoping to improve on that, and many of their performances over the year suggest they might. They performed better against Arizona than Steel City did at ECDX, and better against Dutchland earlier in the year; while other results weren't enough to move them up the rankings, if they replicate their best form of the year at Sugarbush Showdown, they have every chance of proving a few voters wrong.
Carolina and Dutchland sit at eight and nine, swapping places from where they left regionals last year. Both teams got within a jam's worth of points against Boston earlier in the year but neither has had the most taxing of seasons--so this bout could be anybody's.
The number ten spot goes to DC -- who have come out ranked ninth in their three previous visits to regional tournaments. They'll have to pull off at least one upset to do so--and their ability to do that depends on how the rest of the bracket shakes out.


Comments
Third place
"Charm City, the region's perennial third-place finishers of late."
While this might be referencing the final outcome, as for how they enter the tournament it's been a bit of a coin toss. Charm entered the Eastern Regional tournament in 3rd place in 2009 and 2011, but in 2010 (and now 2012) they entered in 4th place.
As they finished
It is indeed a reference to their two third-place finishes over the past two years.
Oh, yes
I didn't mean it as a correction, I meant it as additional insight to those who follow less closely and are interested.
Montreal vs London
I am terribly disappointed that London & Montreal are meeting each other in the first round. I know that it's merely due to the rankings & that's just how the dice fell, but I'd love for them BOTH to have an opportunity to make it to Atlanta.
Normally
Normally I would trot out the "Well, this is why your regular season performance matters because of seeding blah blah blah" but this is a special case, because London's placement is so much more arbitrary relative to the other leagues. If you want both to have a chance, then yes it is disappointing.
That being said, I'm glad as a Charm City fan that Charm isn't playing London round one. In this case I prefer the known to the unknown.
That's how I felt about Ohio v ARRG
at the North Central tournament. I thought both of those teams had a chance to compete for 3rd/4th.
If Ohio hadn't......
been so banged up with injuries by the time of the third place bout with Naptown, we might have seen a much more competitive bout with a different third seed finisher. They looked pretty strong against ARRG and Windy.
Reporting over rumors, please.
and the WFTDA reportedly (but not publicly) instituting a new policy intended to eliminate the possibility of a tactical forfeit
Could you go into more (or really, *any*) detail about this alleged policy?
Nope.
Or to put it in more journalistic terms, "WFTDA officials declined to comment."
That said, I think we've got a pretty good track record of not reporting rumors.
WFTDA Forfeit Policy
Hi everyone,
I'm not aware of a request for comment from DNN on this topic, but this time of year can be very busy and perhaps it lost its way to me.
Regardless, I'm happy to talk in general terms about this new initiative. A forfeit protocol has been on the list of policies we need for several years-- as an organization, we aim to develop policy for situations like this, and let those policies govern our competitive practices and structures, since we don't have a "Commissioner" or owner to make case-by-case decisions. Last year at East Region Playoffs in Baltimore, the need for a policy became obvious and timely, and our Tournaments Committee began drafting. Just like everything in our young sport, this has been vetted and discussed quite a bit, but it is impermanent and flexible, and we will adjust as we need to as we grow and change.
The forfeit policy attempts to discourage strategic forfeits by distinguishing voluntary, strategic forfeits from more traditional, necessary forfeits. Voluntary forfeits are not recorded on the forfeiting team's record and a fine is leveraged. Still, notably, a team can choose to forfeit for strategic reasons, but there is now a structural disincentive and they know this ahead of time. Forfeits for reasons beyond the team's control (typically the type of thing rules section 9.2.7.1 attempts to address) are recorded as a loss.
Thanks, as always, for your avid interest. May we see 17 amazing close games this weekend!
Bloody Mary
Thanks!
Thank you for the clarification; we appreciate it.
Language
The policy has been voted on and fully approved by WFTDA leagues, and is part of the tournament rules and policies for this year. Trying to find the actual language proved troublesome; just as soon as I have it (my efforts are still ongoing) I'll put it in here for you.
Full policy
*EDIT* So, apparently the actual rule is an internal WFTDA document. When the summary was posted, I was under the impression that as a rule for ongoing public events, it was public. I regret the error.
I refer you to the statement from Bloody Mary above.
It seems like having a team
It seems like having a team who strategically forfeits and then has to play the rest of their games with the results not counting could be the kind of thing that leads to situations deeper into the tournament that really hurt my brain. So i will just hope it doesn't come to that.
I, like many fans, thought Dutchland's forfeit was silly because all it did was give them an improved chance at 5th place, which is not the type of thing many of us believe to be worth the grief and hassle of forfeiture. What would really concern me is a 4-seed team ((assuming seedings hold up)) forfeiting their Saturday game against a prohibitive favorite 1-seed ((such as Gotham)), in order to have a theoretically improved chance at winning the third place game on Sunday, and the trip to Championships that comes with it. THAT is a significant enough payoff to make strategic forfeiture a logical consideration. I am glad that particular stratagem has been dealt with by the WFTDA.
Damage Dahl
...is actually on Philly's charter. She seems to be missing from our roster here.
That she does...
I knew she'd moved to Philly and had played for the Liberty Belles this year, but she wasn't on the latest version of the WFTDA charter for Philly that I pasted above.
I shall investigate further!
Floor?
Last I heard this tournament was to be played on the venue's floor, not a Skate Court floor. That info was received back in April though, when our women played at Green Mountain.
Can anyone confirm or deny that? The venue floor is very slippery and could be a factor for teams not used to playing that way.
Thank you
Bazooka Joe
Pioneer Valley Roller Derby
Northampton, MA.
www.pioneervalleyrollerderby.com
Polished concrete
The event is being played on polished concrete, so yes.
From what I hear from those who have tested it, it's awesome. Should be a perfect tournament surface, apparently -- grippy enough, but pretty fast.
You can actually see the interior of the venue here, courtesy of Manish Gosalia.
Huge ref lane, or trick of lens?
From those photos, it appears the ref lane is wider than 10ft. Looks to be almost as wide as the track. Has this been the standard at the previous tournaments?
Put some maple syrup on it!
Put some maple syrup on it! Milk the local color!
Polished Concrete FTW
Glad to see we're playing with whatever the local surface is! Guess we've got concrete for Championships, then?
I can't wait for a wood floor playoff!
yinz!
Man good thing Steel City feels comfortable being the perennial underdog. Now I'm not saying everyone underestimates the ladies in black and gold but it just always seems like they don't always get the respect they deserve. Absolutely cannot wait to see their showing this weekend. YINZYINZYINZ
tell ya what
London loves us some polished concrete.....